The Crash Test Dummy
Fifty years of car safety tuned to the body of an average man.
Read case study →Guiding questionHow do ergonomic considerations influence the design of a product?
Ergonomics is the first topic in the course for a reason. Every object you have ever used was built around an assumption about a body. Once you can name those assumptions, you start seeing them everywhere. The door you have to shove with your shoulder, the shelf you cannot reach without a stool, the phone that needs two hands when your last one needed only one: none of that is bad luck. Somebody chose a dimension, and in doing so somebody decided whose body it would fit.
What makes this topic useful, and not just interesting, is that it gives you evidence. Anthropometric data and percentiles let you argue that a handle is too small or a control is out of reach without saying "it feels wrong to me". That is exactly what examiners want in Paper 2, and exactly what your IA needs when you justify a measurement.
Ergonomics also carries real weight. The crash test dummy case in 1.1.3 shows that deciding whose body counts as "standard" has consequences well beyond comfort. Take the percentile logic seriously now, because it comes back in C1.2 Inclusive Design and anywhere else you have to defend a measurement.
Students must be able toDescribe how ergonomics is used to improve the design of a product by making a design more efficient, usable, functional, effective and safe.
Ergonomics (also called human factors engineering) is the study of how people interact with the products, systems and environments they use. When designers apply ergonomic thinking, the result is products that are safer, more comfortable and more efficient to use.
The field is built on three interlocking disciplines:
A product designed without ergonomic consideration may still function technically. It will be harder to use, more tiring, riskier or inaccessible to some users. Good ergonomic design removes that mismatch.
A practical way to apply ergonomics is to evaluate a design against the five qualities the IB syllabus identifies. Each describes a different way a product can fail to match the person using it:
| Quality | What it means | Applied example |
|---|---|---|
| Efficient | Reduces the effort, time or resources a user needs to complete a task | A chair adjusted so the user's elbows rest at desk height, eliminating shoulder elevation during typing |
| Usable | The product can be operated successfully by the target user population without specialist knowledge | Touchscreen buttons sized to at least 44 × 44 px so different finger sizes can tap accurately |
| Functional | The product performs its purpose without causing harm or requiring workarounds | A handle diameter chosen to fit the grip range of the target users so they can apply the required torque |
| Effective | The user achieves accurate and complete results when using the product | A warning label that uses both colour and symbol, so users with colour vision deficiency still receive the message |
| Safe | Reduces the risk of injury or harm during intended and foreseeable use | A machine guard preventing accidental contact with rotating parts during normal operation |
Ergonomics applied: six product categories
The five qualities above are abstract until you see them in a real object. The categories below are the ones the course uses most often, and each one solves a different kind of body-to-product mismatch.
Students must be able toExplain and use static and dynamic anthropometric data to design for different people and be able to discuss how factors such as age, gender, ethnicity and disability affect the anthropometric data.
Anthropometric data is the systematic collection of human body measurements - height, reach, grip diameter, shoulder width, eye height and hundreds of other dimensions. Designers use this data to set critical product dimensions.
The World Health Organisation, in its report Physical status: the use and interpretation of anthropometry (1995), calls anthropometry "the single most universally applicable, inexpensive and non-invasive method available to assess the size, proportions, and composition of the human body". Non-invasive means nothing enters the body: you are measuring a person from the outside, with a tape or a caliper, not with a scan or a blood test. That is why the method is used everywhere from hospitals to furniture factories.
Two types of data are collected:
How the data is collected, and why it is not perfect
Measurements are taken with instruments such as calipers (a sliding measuring tool with two arms that close onto the body), tape measures, height gauges and, increasingly, 3D body scanners. Whatever the instrument, two things matter: it must be sturdy, and it must be calibrated, meaning it has been checked against a known standard so its readings can be trusted.
Some measurements are far more reliable than others. Height and weight are simple and repeatable. Body fat measured with skinfold calipers is much less reliable across a large sample, because the result depends on exactly where and how hard the technician pinches the skin. When you use a data table, it is worth asking how the numbers in it were obtained.
There is one convention that surprises most students. Anthropometric data is meant to describe the nude body, so that measurements from different studies can be compared. In practice, cultural expectations often make that impossible, so investigators measure clothed subjects and then subtract an allowance for the type and thickness of the clothing worn. Designers sometimes have to add an allowance back on, since a user wearing a winter coat or protective equipment occupies more space than the table says.
Factors that change the data
No two bodies are identical. A person tall enough to fit clothing size L may have arms that fit a size S. Designing for a single "standard human" always excludes real users. Anthropometric data must account for variation across:
Using anthropometric data in practice
A designer identifies which body dimension is critical for the product (seat height, grip width, overhead reach distance), selects the data table for the relevant user population, then determines which end of the distribution to design for. Whether the dimension is about reach or clearance controls the choice of percentile. The rules for that are covered in 1.1.3 Percentiles and 1.1.5 Work Envelopes.
Students must be able toIdentify where the 5th, 50th and 5th–95th percentiles are appropriate for a design scenario.
Anthropometric data for any dimension - such as standing height - follows a normal distribution (also called a Gaussian distribution, or a bell curve). Most people cluster near the middle; fewer people are at the extremes. Percentiles tell you what percentage of the measured population falls at or below a given measurement. Someone in the 70th percentile for a dimension measures the same as, or more than, 70% of the sample.
The statistics behind the curve
A normal distribution is described by just two numbers. The mean is the average value, which sits at the peak of the curve. The standard deviation (written with the Greek letter sigma, σ) measures how spread out the values are around that mean. A small standard deviation gives a tall, narrow curve, meaning most people are close to average. A large one gives a wide, flat curve.
The useful part is that the spread is predictable:
This is why percentile tables work at all. Because the shape of the curve is known, a designer can convert "I want to include 90% of users" into two actual measurements in millimetres, taken from the table at the 5th and 95th percentiles.
A second useful piece of arithmetic concerns mixed populations. Within a single gender, the 5th to 95th percentile range covers 90% of people, because 5% are excluded at each end. In a mixed group that is half male and half female, the same range covers about 95% of people. Only the tallest 5% of men and the smallest 5% of women fall outside it, and since each group is half the sample, that is 2.5% + 2.5% = 5% excluded in total.
Three percentiles are used routinely in design:
Most products should be designed for the 5th–95th percentile range, covering 90% of the population. The extreme 5% at each end are excluded - a deliberate design compromise when the cost of accommodating them is too high.
Designing for the mean alone looks sensible but usually is not. Very few people sit exactly at the average, so a fixed dimension set at the 50th percentile fits almost nobody properly. The problem gets worse when the user group crosses age or gender boundaries, because there is no single average that describes both halves of the group. The crash test dummy case study at the end of this section shows how long that mistake can last once it is built into safety testing.
The choice of percentile range gets harder when the users are still growing. Computer furniture for primary school children has to cover a very wide 5th to 95th percentile range, across both genders and across several years of rapid growth. Get it right and the furniture encourages good posture, reduces fatigue and prevents long-term back problems. Get it wrong, and a child spends six years at a desk that does not fit them.
A useful heuristic when selecting a percentile: ask whether the dimension involves a person reaching towards something or fitting into something.
| Design concern | Percentile to use | Reasoning |
|---|---|---|
| Reach: how far a control or object is from the user | 5th percentile | If the person with the shortest reach can reach it, everyone can |
| Clearance: head height, knee room, corridor width | 95th percentile | If the largest person fits, everyone will |
| One-size product with a fixed dimension | 5th–95th range | Set the minimum at the 5th and the maximum at the 95th to include 90% of users |
| Documenting a reference "typical" user | 50th percentile | The median is used as a reference point only. Do not use it to set fixed design dimensions that must fit a range of people |
Pick a body dimension, a population, and a target percentile. The tool looks up a value using the same 5th/50th/95th logic taught above.
Fifty years of car safety tuned to the body of an average man.
Read case study →Students must be able toExplain the reasons why designers choose adjustability and/or range of sizes for a product, and identify products that use one or both strategies.
No single fixed dimension suits everyone from the 5th to the 95th percentile, so designers have two strategies for fitting a range of bodies. They can make the product adjustable, or they can make it in a range of sizes. Many products use both.
Strategy 1: adjustability
An adjustable product has parts that the user can move, extend or lock into position to suit their own body. One product covers the whole range, and each user sets it up for themselves. This works best when several people share the same product, or when one person needs it set differently at different times.
Adjustability has costs. Every adjustment adds parts, weight and a mechanism that can wear out or break. It also depends on the user: an adjustable chair only helps if the person sitting in it knows how to set it up, and many people never touch the levers.
Strategy 2: a range of sizes
A product made in a range of sizes comes in several fixed versions, and each user chooses the one closest to their body. Each size is simple, with no mechanism to adjust or break, but the manufacturer has to design, make, store and sell every size. This strategy works best when a product is personal, worn or used by one person, or when an adjusting mechanism would be impractical, too expensive or unsafe.
| Size | Chest (cm) | Length (cm) |
|---|---|---|
| XS | 84 | 66 |
| S | 90 | 69 |
| M | 96 | 72 |
| L | 102 | 74 |
| XL | 108 | 76 |
| 2XL | 114 | 78 |
| 3XL | 120 | 80 |
| 4XL | 126 | 82 |
A buyer measures their chest and chooses the closest size. Each step on the chart is 6 cm, so most people fall somewhere between two sizes. Someone with a 105 cm chest sits exactly between L and XL, and neither will fit them perfectly. That gap is what adjustment is for.
Using both strategies
Sizes and adjustment solve different parts of the same problem. The size gets the product close to the user's body, and adjustment closes the remaining gap. That is why so many products combine them.
Clothing combines the two strategies through small details that are easy to overlook. A drawstring lets one pair of tracksuit trousers fit a range of waists. Adjustable shoulder straps on a backpack or a pair of dungarees move the fit up or down the body. Elastic cuffs, a belt with several holes, the Velcro tabs at the wrists of a rain jacket and the toggles on a hood all let a garment bought in a fixed size be fitted to the person wearing it. The buyer with a 105 cm chest can choose the XL and use these features to take up the difference.
Widening the percentile range a product covers is sometimes called design for more types. It is a trade-off rather than a free improvement. Each extra bit of range costs money, adds mechanism or adds stock-keeping complexity, and the cost climbs steeply once you go beyond the 5th to 95th band. Users outside that band usually have to look for a customised solution instead.
Students must be able toExplain the importance of workspace envelopes, adjustability, reach and range of sizes clearance in relation to percentiles and how they are used when designing products.
When designing a workspace, whether it is a cockpit, a kitchen or a production line, a designer needs to map more than body size. They also have to map the space in which the body moves and operates. Three related concepts define that space:
Work envelope (workspace envelope) - the three-dimensional space that a person can comfortably reach and operate within from a fixed position. Imagine a sphere of reachable space around a seated operator. All critical controls must fall within this envelope; otherwise the user must stretch, lean or shift in ways that increase fatigue and error rate. The size of the work envelope changes with body size, so it must be defined using percentile data.
Reach - the maximum distance a person can extend their arm to contact or operate something. Reach is a 5th percentile design concern: if the smallest user can reach every control, everyone can. Place the most frequently used controls in the nearest zone of the work envelope.
Clearance - the minimum space needed to fit part of the body without obstruction: head clearance in a doorway, knee clearance under a desk, shoulder width in a corridor. Clearance is a 95th percentile concern: design so the largest user fits through or into the space, and everyone else will too.
Applying these correctly means using different percentiles for different problems: reach calls for 5th percentile data; clearance calls for 95th percentile data. A single percentile cannot solve both simultaneously. This is one reason adjustable workstations exist.
Why one percentile is never enough: multivariate variation
The usual rule for adjustability is to cover from the 5th percentile female to the 95th percentile male. That sounds like it guarantees 95% coverage, and it would, if human bodies were always in the same proportion. They are not. A tall person can have short arms; a short person can have proportionally long arms. Being 50th percentile for height tells you almost nothing about someone's shoulder width or seated eye height.
Multivariate analysis is the statistical method used to handle several body dimensions at once instead of one at a time. The uncomfortable finding it produces is this: when a product depends on several dimensions together, designing each one to the 5th–95th range still leaves more than 5% of people excluded on at least one dimension. Someone who fits the seat depth may not fit the armrest width.
Designers accept this rather than solve it, because the cost of accommodating every possible combination of dimensions rises very steeply and is rarely justified. What they can do is identify which dimension actually limits the design. In a workstation, that limiting factor is usually arm reach, which is why the reach envelope is defined as a three-dimensional space rather than a single distance.
Where the data comes from
Reliable data is essential before you can define a reach envelope for a broad population. Four sources are commonly used:
Every one of these can be distorted by clothing, which adds bulk and restricts movement. A reach envelope measured in a t-shirt does not describe the same worker in a padded jacket, gloves and a helmet.
Built for one hand size, then rebuilt for everyone else.
Read spotlight →
One height range, covered by a motor instead of a size chart.
Read spotlight →
When adjustment alone isn't enough, and you need three different frames instead of one.
Read spotlight →Students must be able toExplain limiting aspects of user capabilities, including users' visual accuracy, colour perception, strengths, fatigue, muscle control and hearing thresholds.
Physiology is the study of how the body's systems function, respond and break down under use. For designers, the relevant question is: what are the limits of what the human body can do, and how does the product stay within those limits?
Visual accuracy and colour perception. The eye can only see fine detail at the very centre of the visual field, in a small area of the retina called the fovea. Everything outside that centre is peripheral vision, which detects movement well but detail poorly. Approximately 8% of males have some form of colour vision deficiency, meaning they cannot reliably tell certain colours apart. Designs that rely on colour alone to carry critical information (red = danger, green = safe) exclude these users. Good design treats colour as one channel among several, so that shape, symbol and position repeat the same message for anyone who cannot see the colour difference.
Muscle strength and fatigue. The force a person can exert (gripping, lifting, pushing) varies widely by age, gender, hand size and physical condition. Biomechanics is the study of the mechanical laws governing movement in living bodies: levers, joints and load paths. Designing a product that requires excessive force can cause injury over time. A rubber jar opener with a serrated strip works by increasing friction and mechanical advantage, allowing the same torque to be produced with far less hand force. This reduces fatigue and injury risk for users with reduced grip strength.
Muscle control. Fine motor control (precise finger and hand movements) decreases with age, fatigue, cold and certain medical conditions. Products requiring precise input, with small buttons or fine-tuned controls, can exclude users with reduced motor control.
Hearing thresholds. Human hearing is most sensitive in the 1,000–4,000 Hz range. High-frequency hearing loss is common with age. Auditory warnings must be designed to reach users with reduced hearing and must not be masked by background noise in the environment where the product is used.
Every design contains a biomechanical assumption
Whenever a designer specifies a control, they are quietly assuming something about the user's body. That a finger can press this button hard enough. That a wrist can twist this switch. That a hand can turn the handle of a can opener or a corkscrew. Those assumptions come from anthropometric data describing the population's strength, dexterity and fine motor control, and they are only as good as the population the data was taken from.
Several common conditions break the assumption. Age-related muscle weakness, arthritis (painful inflammation and stiffness of the joints), Parkinson's disease (a nervous system disorder causing tremor and slowed movement) and multiple sclerosis (damage to the nerves, causing weakness and loss of coordination) all reduce the force and precision a user can produce. Designers respond either by adapting the original design or by developing adaptive technologies, which are devices that amplify what the user's body can do rather than replacing it.
Packaging is where this fails most often. Older consumers regularly report difficulty with jar lids, soft drink bottle tops, ring pulls and child-resistant screw caps. Reduced grip strength and arthritis turn a task the designer never thought about into a daily obstacle. Better packaging, or a grip aid that supplies mechanical advantage, solves it cheaply.
A different biomechanical problem appears when equipment adds load to the body. Protective helmets are worn in many jobs and sports, and the neck muscles must resist that extra weight for hours. It becomes serious in military and search-and-rescue work, where night vision goggles or a head-mounted display are attached to the front of the helmet. The added mass sits forward of the neck joint, so it acts on a longer lever arm and multiplies the strain.
Biomechanics in sporting equipment
Sport is the clearest showcase for biomechanics, because equipment is refined to improve performance, reduce fatigue or prevent injury. Products are usually developed for elite athletes first, then mass-produced for everyone else.
Biomechanical engineers work on far more ordinary products too, from backpacks to child safety harnesses, and they use the same analysis to investigate how a product is used, misused or found difficult. Applied across the whole population, including children, older adults and people with disabilities, this work becomes design for inclusion.
Designing around the limits of sight
Because vision carries most of the information a user receives, visual design has to be unambiguous: the right information, in the right place, at the moment it is needed, with nothing distracting around it. Designers are responsible for asking how the information will actually be used. A door that opens in only one direction should say push or pull, because nothing in the shape of a flat plate tells the user which is which.
Colour does several jobs at once, and it is worth separating them:
Designing around the limits of hearing
Hearing is used deliberately in design for four main purposes:
Thermal comfort
A person's experience of a given temperature depends on air temperature, humidity, air movement, radiant heat, clothing insulation, metabolic rate and individual physiology. Two people in the same room at the same thermostat setting may experience it very differently, depending on their clothing, activity level, body composition and acclimatisation. A single fixed temperature cannot satisfy all occupants of a shared space. Designers and facilities managers address this with zoned temperature controls, personal desk fans or heaters, and flexible dress codes. The underlying logic is the same as designing products in a range of sizes: no single fixed setting works for everyone, so the environment must allow for variation.
Students must be able toDiscuss how human senses (smell, sound, touch, taste and vision) are used to influence the design and development of products.
Psychology, in the context of ergonomics, focuses on how the mind receives and interprets information from the environment through all five senses. Products communicate through sensory channels whether their designers intend it or not. Understanding how the brain processes sensory input allows designers to communicate more clearly, create safer products and shape user experience.
Sight (vision). The most information-dense sense. Designers control colour, shape, size, contrast and motion to direct attention and communicate meaning. Orange is used for life rings, life vests and rescue equipment because it is the most easily detected colour against the sea surface and in low-light conditions. The choice is grounded in visual psychology. Text contrast ratios must meet accessibility standards to remain readable for users with reduced vision.
Space and visual boundaries also carry psychological weight. High partitions in an office create a sense of personal territory and acoustic privacy. Lowering them increases visual connection and openness but reduces defensible space, the zone a person perceives as their own and feels in control of. The term was coined by John Calhoun in the 1940s, and the amount of personal space an individual needs varies with culture and upbringing rather than being fixed. Designers balance these competing effects when planning shared environments such as open-plan offices and libraries.
Hearing (sound). Auditory signals carry urgency: a car horn, a fire alarm, a hospital monitor. The tone, pitch, rhythm and volume of a sound communicate different levels of emergency. A warning tone that blends with background noise fails its purpose. Sound design must account for the acoustic environment where the product is used.
Touch (haptic feedback). Textured surfaces, vibrations and physical resistance communicate information without requiring vision or sound. Tactile paving (the raised, bumped tiles at pedestrian crossings) signals a safe crossing point to visually impaired users by touch alone. Digital devices use haptic feedback to confirm input, guide navigation and signal alerts without requiring the user to look at a screen or hear a sound. See the concept introduction below for a full explanation.
Smell (olfaction). Natural gas is odourless; a sulphur compound is added to give it a distinctive smell because the brain responds rapidly to unfamiliar odours. Safety design sometimes uses smell as a warning channel when visual or auditory channels may be missed.
Taste. Less commonly a design consideration, but relevant in food products, medical devices (pill coatings designed to prevent accidental ingestion) and child safety (bitter coatings on hazardous household products).
Psychological data in product design: the mobile phone
Phones are a good example because the technology inside two competing models is often nearly identical. What differs is everything the user senses: colour, shape, material, surface finish, the weight in the hand, the way the screen lights up. Manufacturers vary these deliberately to appeal to different consumer groups. It is not only functions and services that sell a phone. Physical design choices aimed at a buyer's psychological needs, such as wanting to appear serious, playful, expensive or discreet, do a large share of the work.
Environmental psychology and the office
Environmental psychology studies the relationship between an environment and the people inside it. For an indoor office, five factors are usually assessed together:
There is a widely used benchmark for judging the result. When about 80% of the occupants report feeling comfortable, the space is considered to have achieved "reasonable comfort". The figure is deliberately not 100%, because individual responses vary too much for that to be achievable. Note also that air temperature on its own is not a valid measure of comfort: all five factors above contribute.
Open-plan offices exist mainly to raise worker density and free up unrestricted space, by removing interior walls or shrinking partitions. The gains are real. Communication barriers drop, the space feels larger, and air and daylight move more freely. So do the costs: more noise transfer, less personal privacy and more visual distraction. The usual compromise is to use carefully placed low barriers to create defensible space within an open layout, so employees can still customise a small area and feel a degree of comfort, safety and control.
To measure any of this rather than guess at it, office designers can use the Physical Work Environment Satisfaction Questionnaire (PWESQ). It surveys staff on the environmental factors listed above alongside physical demands and work systems, and it turns a subjective argument about whether an office "feels bad" into data a designer can act on.
Haptic feedback is the use of vibration, force or texture to send information to a user through the sense of touch. The word "haptic" comes from the Greek haptikos, meaning "able to touch." Designers use it as a communication channel when visual or auditory feedback is unavailable, insufficient or would disturb others.
When discussing haptic feedback in an IB context, consider both what it enables (confirmation without sound, navigation for visually impaired users, physical immersion in gaming) and its limits (the sensation is lost if the device rests on a surface rather than in the hand; not all users have full tactile sensitivity; cultural expectations around vibration vary).
Every sensory or physiological design decision is really a bet about who the user is, and sometimes that bet is wrong. A red-green traffic light relies on colour vision that roughly 1 in 12 men don't fully have. A smoke alarm's high-pitched beep sits right in the frequency range that presbycusis (age-related hearing loss, a physiological decline) erodes first, making it least audible to the older adults most at risk from a house fire.
Pick a product you use every day and find the sensory or physiological assumption built into it. Whose body was it designed around? Who does that assumption quietly exclude, and which research method from A2.1 would have caught the problem before the product ever shipped?
Eleven questions covering all seven learning objectives. Select one answer per question, then click "Check all answers" to see your score and the explanations.
Tokyo Metro's 17000 series trains replaced the 7000 series, first introduced in 1974, on the Yurakucho and Fukutoshin lines in Tokyo. Seated passengers sit on long benches facing each other across the car. Standing passengers hold hand straps that hang from rails above the seats.
The 17000 series changed several dimensions from the cars it replaced. Each seat position on the bench is 460 mm wide, against 430 mm in the 7000 series. The hand straps above the seats hang 1660 mm above the floor. At the ends of each car the straps hang 80 mm lower, at 1580 mm, which the operator describes as a barrier-free measure, meaning one intended to make the train accessible to more people. Every car also has a free space for wheelchair and pushchair users.
(a) State the percentile of standing grip reach that should be used to set the height of a hand strap, see Figure 1. [1]
(b) Outline why the width of each seat position was increased from 430 mm to 460 mm, see Figure 1. [2]
(c) Explain why the designers fitted hand straps at two fixed heights rather than straps that passengers could adjust, see Figure 1. [3]
(a) The 5th percentile.
(b) The width of a seat position is a clearance dimension, so it has to be set from the upper end of the range, around the 95th percentile of hip breadth, or larger passengers spread into the next position. The 7000 series was designed in the early 1970s, and anthropometric data changes over time, so 430 mm was based on a smaller population than the one using the trains today. The extra 30 mm also allows for winter coats and for bags held on the lap.
(c) A strap has to be reachable by the shortest passengers who use it, so its height is set from the 5th percentile of standing grip reach. That still leaves out passengers below the 5th percentile, such as children and many older people. A strap low enough for them would hang at face height for taller passengers walking through the car, which is a clearance problem. Two heights solve this with a range of sizes: the straps over the seats suit most adults, the lower straps at the car ends serve shorter passengers, and each passenger chooses a height by where they stand. Adjustable straps would need a mechanism, which adds cost and parts that wear in a component that must hold a passenger's weight when the train brakes. In a crowded train there is also no time to adjust a strap before holding it, and every strap would be left at the last user's height.
(a) Percentiles aid in the selection of appropriate anthropometric data to satisfy the majority of a user population.
• 5th percentile ✓
• 5th percentile of the shorter user group, for example adult women ✓
Award [1] for the correct percentile up to [1 max]. Do not credit the 50th or 95th percentile, or a range.
(b) In design, consideration must be given to work envelopes, reach, clearance, adjustability and range of sizes.
• Seat width is a clearance dimension ✓
• Clearance is set from an upper percentile, such as the 95th, so that larger users fit ✓
• At 430 mm, passengers with a larger hip or shoulder breadth spread into the next seat position ✓
• Anthropometric data changes over time; the 7000 series dates from 1974 and adult body dimensions have increased since ✓
• Winter clothing and bags held on the lap add to the width each passenger needs ✓
• Wider positions reduce contact between neighbouring passengers, improving comfort ✓
Award [1] for each relevant brief point / summary of why the width of each seat position was increased on the 17000 series up to [2 max].
(c) To ensure products are appropriate to a range of percentiles, designers can choose to design products to be adjustable and/or to be produced in a range of sizes.
Range of sizes:
• Strap height is set from the 5th percentile of reach so that most passengers can reach it ✓
• Passengers below the 5th percentile, such as children, older people and some disabled passengers, need a lower strap ✓
• Two heights give a range of sizes, and passengers choose one by where they stand ✓
• Keeping the lower straps at the car ends keeps them clear of taller passengers moving along the car ✓
Adjustability:
• An adjustable strap needs a mechanism, which adds cost and parts that wear ✓
• A mechanism is a weak point in a part that carries a passenger's weight under braking ✓
• In a crowded car there is no time to adjust a strap before holding it ✓
• Each strap would be left at the previous passenger's height ✓
• Fixed straps need less maintenance across a large fleet ✓
Award [1] for each relevant reason / cause explaining why the 17000 series uses two fixed strap heights rather than adjustable straps up to [3 max]. Award a maximum of [2] where the response addresses only the range of sizes or only adjustability.
In an intensive care unit (ICU), each patient is connected to a bedside monitor that tracks their heart rhythm, blood oxygen, blood pressure and breathing. When a reading crosses a limit set by a nurse, or a sensor stops working, the monitor raises an alarm. Some alarms sound a tone. Others only show a message on the screen.
In March 2013, researchers at the University of California, San Francisco recorded every alarm from the GE Healthcare Solar 8000i monitors on 77 ICU beds for 31 days. The nurses responding to them work shifts of 8 to 12 hours. The researchers found that alarms were set off by events as harmless as a patient brushing their teeth.
(a) State the human sense a nurse uses to detect the alarms that are not audible, see Figure 2. [1]
(b) Outline why the monitor uses an audible tone rather than an on-screen message for its most serious alarms, see Figure 2. [2]
(c) Explain how the monitor's alarms could be redesigned so that nurses hear fewer audible alarms without missing serious ones, see Figure 2. [3]
(a) Sight.
(b) Hearing does not depend on where the nurse is looking. A nurse caring for another patient, or away from the bed, cannot see the screen, but can hear a tone from across the unit and respond straight away, where an on-screen message waits until someone happens to look at it.
(c) Nurses hear 187 audible alarms per bed per day across a shift of up to 12 hours, which causes fatigue, and because most heart-rhythm alarms are false they learn to treat the sound as meaningless. The number of alarms could be cut at the source by letting nurses set alarm limits to suit each patient and by adding a short delay, so that brief harmless events such as movement do not trigger an alarm. Alarms that do not need urgent action, such as a loose sensor, could be shown as on-screen messages or a light visible across the unit, which uses sight instead of hearing. The serious alarms that remain could use a distinct tone for each level of urgency, or vibrate a device carried by the nurse responsible, so that a nurse can recognise a serious alarm by hearing or touch alone without the whole unit being exposed to it.
(a) Psychology is concerned with the study of the human mind and involves the study of all the human senses that may be involved in sending information to the brain.
• Sight / vision ✓
Award [1] for the correct sense up to [1 max]. Do not credit hearing.
(b) Students must be able to discuss how human senses (smell, sound, touch, taste and vision) are used to influence the design and development of products.
• Hearing does not depend on where the nurse is looking ✓
• A nurse caring for another patient or away from the bed cannot see the screen ✓
• Sound carries across the unit, so any nurse nearby can respond ✓
• A tone attracts attention immediately, where a message waits to be noticed ✓
• A tone set above the background noise of the unit is heard over other activity ✓
• A distinct tone tells the nurse the alarm is serious before reaching the monitor ✓
Award [1] for each relevant brief point / summary of why the monitor's most serious alarms are audible up to [2 max].
(c) Physiology is the study of systems and biomechanics within the human body, their responses, limitations and capabilities, including fatigue and hearing thresholds.
Fewer alarms:
• Nurses set alarm limits to suit each patient, so fewer false alarms are raised ✓
• A short delay stops brief harmless events, such as movement, from triggering an alarm ✓
• Fewer false alarms means nurses treat each alarm as meaningful rather than learning to ignore them ✓
• Fewer audible alarms reduce nurse fatigue over a shift of up to 12 hours ✓
Using other senses:
• Alarms that are not urgent, such as a loose sensor, are shown as on-screen messages (sight) ✓
• A light visible across the unit shows which bed needs attention without sound ✓
• A device carried by the nurse responsible vibrates (touch), so only that nurse is alerted ✓
Keeping serious alarms noticeable:
• A distinct tone for each level of urgency lets a nurse judge urgency by hearing alone ✓
• Keeping sound for the serious alarms makes each tone stand out when it occurs ✓
Award [1] for each relevant reason / cause explaining how the Solar 8000i's alarms could be redesigned so that nurses hear fewer audible alarms without missing serious ones up to [3 max]. Award a maximum of [2] where changes are listed without linking them to the nurses' senses or capabilities.
A city food delivery company equips its riders with an electric bicycle and an insulated backpack. Riders work shifts of up to nine hours and complete between twenty and thirty drop-offs. The bicycle is shared: a rider is allocated whichever bike is charged at the start of the shift. (This company is invented for this question.)
The frame is supplied in one size. Saddle height adjusts over a 180 mm range by a quick-release clamp. The handlebar height is fixed.
(a) Identify two adjustments the shared bicycle would need in order to fit riders from the 5th to the 95th percentile, see Figure 3. [2]
The backpack is carried on the rider's back and loaded from the top. Full, it weighs 9 kg, and the load sits above and behind the rider's shoulders. Riders report pain in the lower back and shoulders towards the end of a shift.
(b) Outline why carrying the loaded backpack for a whole shift leads to pain in the lower back and shoulders. [2]
Riders work through winter evenings in rain and temperatures near freezing. The delivery application is operated on a phone clipped to the handlebar, using a touchscreen. Riders wear gloves.
(c) Describe how low temperature affects a rider's ability to operate the handlebar-mounted touchscreen. [2]
The company proposes replacing the plain dark jackets riders currently wear with a high-visibility kit: a jacket in fluorescent yellow with retro-reflective strips at the shoulders and wrists, and reflective bands worn at the ankles. Retro-reflective material sends light back in the direction it came from.
(d) Explain how the proposed kit uses the limits of human vision to make riders easier for drivers to see, see Figure 4. [4]
(a) Saddle height, and handlebar height or reach to the handlebar.
(b) The 9 kg load sits high and behind the shoulders, so it pulls the rider backwards and the rider leans forward to stay balanced. The muscles of the lower back and shoulders hold that posture and carry the straps for up to nine hours without rest, and muscles held working in one position tire, so fatigue builds through the shift and turns into pain.
(c) Cold reduces the blood flow to the fingers, so the rider loses feeling in their fingertips and has less fine muscle control, which makes it harder to hit a small target on the screen accurately. Gloves worn against the cold make the fingertip larger and less precise, and ordinary gloves do not register on a touchscreen at all, so the rider must either take a glove off in the cold or miss touches.
(d) In daylight and at dusk, fluorescent yellow appears brighter than the colours around it and contrasts strongly with the greys and browns of a street, so a driver sees the rider from further away than they would see a dark jacket, which is close in colour to the road.
At night the eye's colour perception is weak, so the yellow alone no longer helps. The retro-reflective strips work instead: they send the light of a car's headlights back towards that car, so the rider appears bright to exactly the driver who is approaching. Because the strips are at the wrists and ankles they move as the rider pedals and signals, and movement catches a driver's attention. Placed at the shoulders, wrists and ankles they also mark out the shape of a person, so the driver recognises a cyclist rather than an unknown light.
(a) Consideration must be given to work envelopes, reach, clearance, adjustability and range of sizes.
• Saddle height ✓
• Handlebar height ✓
• Reach from saddle to handlebar ✓
• Brake lever reach from the grip ✓
• Saddle fore and aft position ✓
• Crank length ✓
Award [1] for each relevant adjustment identified up to [2 max]. Do not credit saddle height twice under two descriptions.
(b) Physiology is the study of systems and biomechanics within the human body, their responses, limitations and capabilities. Students must be able to explain limiting aspects of user capabilities, including strengths and fatigue.
• The load sits high and behind the shoulders, pulling the rider backwards ✓
• The rider leans forward to stay balanced, an awkward posture held for the whole shift ✓
• The lower back muscles work continuously to hold that posture ✓
• The straps press on the shoulders for up to nine hours ✓
• Muscles held working in one position without rest tire quickly, so fatigue builds through the shift ✓
• The load and the length of the shift together exceed what the muscles can sustain, causing pain ✓
Award [1] for each relevant brief point / summary of why carrying the backpack for a whole shift leads to back and shoulder pain up to [2 max]. Award a maximum of [1] where the response states only that the pack is heavy.
(c) Students must be able to explain limiting aspects of user capabilities, including users' visual accuracy, colour perception, strengths, fatigue, muscle control and hearing thresholds.
• Cold reduces blood flow to the fingers, so the rider loses feeling in the fingertips ✓
• Fine muscle control declines, so the rider is less accurate at small targets ✓
• Gloves make the fingertip larger and less precise on the screen ✓
• Ordinary gloves do not register on a touchscreen, so touches are missed ✓
• Shivering makes it harder to hold a finger steady on a target ✓
• Removing a glove to use the screen exposes the hand to the cold again ✓
Award [1] for each detail, leading to an account of how low temperature affects the rider's operation of the touchscreen, up to [2 max]. Credit effects on the hand or on the use of gloves.
(d) Students must be able to explain limiting aspects of user capabilities, including users' visual accuracy and colour perception, and discuss how human senses, including vision, are used to influence the design and development of products.
Daylight and dusk:
• Fluorescent yellow appears brighter than the colours around it ✓
• It contrasts with the greys and browns of a street, so the rider stands out ✓
• A bright, high-contrast colour is seen from further away than a dark one ✓
• The current dark jacket is close in colour to the road, so it is hard to see ✓
Night:
• Colour perception is weak in low light, so the yellow alone does not make the rider visible ✓
• Retro-reflective strips send headlight light back towards the car it came from ✓
• The rider therefore appears bright to the driver who is approaching ✓
Placement:
• Strips at the wrists and ankles move as the rider pedals and signals, and movement catches the driver's attention ✓
• Strips at the shoulders, wrists and ankles mark out the shape of a person, so the driver recognises a cyclist ✓
Award [1] for each relevant detail / reason / cause relating to how the proposed kit uses the limits of human vision to make riders easier for drivers to see up to [4 max]. Award a maximum of [2] where the response addresses daytime or night-time only.
Linking Questions