Curriculum/DP Design/A3.1 Material Classification & Properties

Material Classification & Properties | A3.1

Guiding questionHow do material properties and classifications aid material selection for a specified manufacturing process or product?

This topic is mostly about learning to be precise, and precision is what separates a design justification from an opinion. "This material is strong" is not a statement anyone can check. Strong in tension or in compression? Stiff, or tough? Hard, or just heavy? Materials science has spent a couple of centuries building words that each mean exactly one thing, and once you have them you can say what you actually mean and then defend it.

It is tempting to treat this as a vocabulary list you memorise for Paper 1 and then forget. Resist that, because every material decision you make for the rest of the course runs through here. B3.1 asks you to choose a material and justify it, A3.2 and B3.2 ask you to predict how it behaves under load, and C3.2 asks what happens to it after the product dies. Get the properties straight now and those topics become mostly arithmetic. Skip them and you will be guessing for two years.

Students must be able toExplain how and why materials are classified and discuss the advantages of classifying materials in terms of physical, chemical and mechanical properties.

Classification systems allow designers and engineers to organise the vast range of available materials into manageable groups, making comparison and selection practical. The first recorded material classification system is attributed to Aristotle (384–322 BCE), who grouped matter by elemental properties. Modern classification follows three broad property categories:

  • Physical properties: measurable characteristics that do not involve a chemical reaction. Density, thermal expansion, thermal conductivity, melting point, electrical conductivity and resistivity.
  • Chemical properties: how a material interacts with other substances. Corrosion resistance, reactivity with food, hygroscopy, flammability.
  • Mechanical properties: how a material responds to applied forces. Strength, stiffness, toughness, hardness, malleability, elasticity, plasticity, ductility.

Advantages of classification:

  • Enables systematic comparison across large numbers of candidate materials using databases and selection tools (e.g., CES EduPack)
  • Allows designers to specify performance requirements in measurable terms that suppliers and manufacturers can match
  • Supports decision-making across the full product lifecycle, from material extraction and processing to end-of-life recycling or biodegradation
  • Provides a shared technical vocabulary that bridges design, engineering, and manufacturing disciplines
By Lekritz - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikipedia
CategoryWhat it measuresInvolves a chemical change?Examples
PhysicalWhat the material isNoDensity, thermal expansion, thermal conductivity, melting point, electrical conductivity/resistivity
ChemicalWhat the material does when it meets other substancesYesCorrosion resistance, reactivity with food, hygroscopy, flammability
MechanicalWhat the material can withstand under forceNoStrength, stiffness, toughness, hardness, ductility
Classification diagram

Metals: ferrous and non-ferrous

Hover or focus an example for a quick note, or click it for more detail on how it gets used in design technology.

Metals
Ferrous

Contains iron, which gives good strength but leaves it prone to rusting unless treated, coated or alloyed against corrosion.

Non-ferrous

Contains no iron, so it resists corrosion far better than ferrous metals. Usually lighter, but often more costly to produce.

Classification diagram

Composites: reinforcement and matrix

Hover or focus an example for a quick note, or click it for more detail on how it gets used in design technology.

Composites
Reinforcement

The strong, stiff phase running through a composite, usually fibres or particles that carry most of the load.

Matrix

The binder that holds the reinforcement in place, transferring load between fibres or particles and protecting them.

centralmiddlezhong preview
Text Adventure Game
Central Middlezhong Adventure

Help the people of Central Middlezhong to build new structures and demonstrate your knowledge of material classification and selection criteria. →

Students must be able toDiscuss frame, shell, solid and combination (for example, frame and shell) structures, and how they are used in the design of products. They need to understand that materials are classified into natural and human-made, including for example timbers, polymers, metals, glass, textiles, composites, smart materials and biomaterials.

Materials are grouped by their origin into natural (found in or derived from nature) and human-made (synthesised or significantly processed by people):

  • Timbers: natural. Softwoods (pine, spruce, cedar) from coniferous trees; hardwoods (oak, teak, mahogany) from deciduous trees. Engineered wood (plywood, MDF, LVL) is human-made from timber by-products.
  • Polymers: largely human-made. Thermoplastics (polyethylene, polypropylene, ABS, PET, all of which can be remelted and reshaped); thermosets (epoxy, polyester resin, permanently cross-linked and unable to be remelted); elastomers (rubber, silicone, flexible and able to return to shape).
  • Metals: processed from natural ores. Ferrous (contain iron: mild steel, stainless steel, cast iron) and non-ferrous (aluminium, copper, titanium, brass, bronze).
  • Glass: human-made from natural silica (SiO₂) with additives. Soda-lime glass, borosilicate glass, optical glass, toughened and laminated safety glass.
  • Textiles: natural fibres (cotton, wool, silk, linen) and human-made fibres (nylon, polyester, Kevlar, carbon fibre).
  • Composites: human-made combinations of two or more materials (covered in 3.1.7).
  • Smart materials: human-made materials with properties that respond to environmental stimuli (covered in 3.1.8).
  • Biomaterials / biodegradable materials: natural or human-made materials that break down biologically (covered in 3.1.9).

Structural forms and their material implications: Product structures are often classified as frame, shell, solid, or combination, and the material choice is directly linked to the structural form:

  • Frame structures: load-bearing members (rods, beams, tubes) connected at joints; requires materials with high strength-to-weight ratio (steel, aluminium, carbon fibre)
  • Shell structures: thin curved surfaces carry loads through their geometry; requires materials that can be formed into thin sheets (sheet steel, fibreglass, carbon fibre)
  • Solid (mass) structures: material fills the entire volume; suitable where compressive strength is primary (concrete, stone, cast iron)
  • Combination structures: use two or more structural forms together (e.g., a car body combining a steel frame with sheet metal shell panels)

Students must be able toEvaluate the physical, chemical and mechanical properties to ensure the selection of the most appropriate material for a specific purpose.

No single material excels in all properties. Material selection is a multi-criteria optimisation problem: the designer must identify the properties most critical to the product's function, environment of use, manufacturing process, cost constraints, and end-of-life requirements, then find the material (or combination of materials) that best satisfies those criteria simultaneously.

Key considerations in material selection:

  • Functional requirements: what the material must do (support loads, conduct electricity, insulate heat, resist chemicals, flex without breaking)
  • Manufacturing requirements: how the material will be shaped (casting, machining, forming, moulding, additive manufacturing); some processes require specific material characteristics (e.g., die casting requires materials with low melting points)
  • Environmental conditions of use: temperature range, exposure to moisture, chemicals, UV radiation, or biological agents; outdoor use demands corrosion resistance; food contact demands chemical inertness
  • Aesthetic characteristics: surface finish quality, colour, translucency/opacity, texture, perceived quality ("feel" and "weight" that communicate value to users); materials communicate brand identity beyond their function
  • Cost and availability: raw material cost, processing cost, lead time; exotic materials with excellent properties may be impractical for high-volume production
  • Sustainability: embodied energy, recyclability, biodegradability, source (renewable vs. finite), and life-cycle environmental impact

In practice, designers use material selection charts (Ashby charts) to plot two properties simultaneously (e.g., strength vs. density), allowing rapid visual comparison of material families and identification of candidates for more detailed evaluation.

Concept: Ashby Charts

An Ashby chart is a scatter plot with one material property on each axis (commonly logarithmic scales), such as Young's modulus against density. Each material family (metals, polymers, ceramics, composites, foams) occupies its own cluster or "bubble" on the chart rather than a single point, because properties vary within a family depending on processing and composition.

This connects to the property categories introduced earlier in this topic: a designer who has already weighed up the functional, manufacturing, environmental, aesthetic, cost, and sustainability requirements for a product can draw a target zone on the chart (for example, "stiffness above 50 GPa and density below 3000 kg/m³") and immediately see which material families fall inside it. This turns a verbal list of requirements into a visual shortlist, narrowing dozens of candidate materials down to a handful worth investigating in detail.

Ashby chart plotting Young's modulus against density for different material families

Students must be able toExplain density, thermal expansion, thermal conductivity, melting point, electrical resistivity and electrical conductivity.

Physical properties describe what a material is. They can be measured without causing a chemical reaction or permanently altering the material's identity.

  • Density (ρ): mass per unit volume (kg/m³ or g/cm³). A material's density determines structural weight and influences shipping cost, handling, and user experience. Aluminium (2700 kg/m³) is roughly one-third the density of steel (7800 kg/m³), making it attractive for weight-sensitive applications like aircraft and bicycle frames.
  • Thermal expansion (coefficient of thermal expansion, α): the fractional change in length per degree of temperature change (K⁻¹). Engineering components operating across temperature ranges must accommodate differential expansion. For mild steel, α ≈ 11 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹, meaning a 1-metre steel rod expands by 0.011 mm for every 1°C rise. Bridges need expansion joints; pipelines need flexible connectors.
  • Thermal conductivity (k): the rate at which heat flows through a material (W/m·K). High thermal conductivity (copper, aluminium) is needed in heat exchangers and cooking pans. Low thermal conductivity (wood, expanded polystyrene, aerogel) is required for thermal insulation in buildings and packaging.
  • Melting point (Tm): the temperature at which a solid transitions to a liquid. A high melting point (tungsten: 3422°C) is needed for materials used in high-temperature environments. A low melting point is required for casting and soldering processes. Thermoplastics soften progressively rather than having a sharp melting point.
  • Electrical conductivity (σ) and electrical resistivity (ρe): conductivity is the ease with which electrons flow through a material (S/m); resistivity is its reciprocal (Ω·m). Conductors (copper, aluminium, silver) have very low resistivity; insulators (rubber, ceramic, glass) have very high resistivity; semiconductors (silicon, germanium) fall in between and can be tuned by doping.

Students must be able toExplain corrosion resistance, reactivity (food safe), hygroscopy and flammability.

Chemical properties describe what a material does when it encounters other substances. They involve chemical reactions that alter the material's composition.

  • Corrosion resistance: the ability to resist degradation by chemical reactions with the environment (oxygen, moisture, acids, salts). Stainless steel and aluminium resist corrosion through passivation: they spontaneously form a nanometre-thick chromium oxide (stainless steel) or aluminium oxide (aluminium) surface layer that is stable and adherent, blocking further oxidation of the underlying metal. This self-healing layer reforms if scratched. Iron and mild steel do not passivate; instead they form loose, flaky iron oxide (rust) that continues to expose fresh metal, causing progressive degradation.
  • Reactivity with food (food safety): materials used in food contact applications must not release chemicals into food. Three relevant reactions are: migration (plasticisers or monomers diffusing from packaging into food), oxidation (fats and oils reacting with oxygen, accelerated by some metals), and hydrolysis (water breaking down polymer chains). Stainless steel, glass, HDPE, and food-grade polypropylene are used in food contact applications because they are chemically inert under normal conditions. Regulations (e.g., EU 10/2011, FDA CFR Title 21) specify migration limits.
  • Hygroscopy: the tendency to absorb and retain moisture from the surrounding environment. Hygroscopic materials (wood, nylon, PVA, silica gel, salt) swell, weaken, or lose dimensional stability when they absorb water. Hydrophobic materials (wax, polyethylene, PTFE) repel water. Hygroscopicity is critical for packaging (a hygroscopic package protecting a moisture-sensitive product would be counterproductive), storage, and applications where dimensional accuracy is essential.
  • Flammability: the ease with which a material ignites and sustains combustion. Measured parameters include the ignition temperature, rate of flame spread, and heat release rate. Materials are classified as flammable, combustible, or non-combustible. Designers specify flame-retardant additives or inherently non-flammable materials (ceramics, metals, glass) for products used near ignition sources or required to meet fire safety standards.

Students must be able toExplain tensile and compressive strength, stiffness, toughness, hardness, malleability, elasticity, plasticity and ductility.

Mechanical properties describe what a material can withstand when forces are applied.

  • Tensile strength (Ultimate Tensile Strength, UTS): the maximum stress a material can withstand before fracturing when pulled. Measured in MPa (megapascals). Steel structural members, cables, and tensioned fasteners require high UTS.
  • Compressive strength: the maximum stress a material can withstand when compressed (squeezed). Concrete is strong in compression (≈ 20–40 MPa) but weak in tension; steel is strong in both (hence reinforced concrete combines the two).
  • Stiffness (Young's modulus, E): resistance to elastic deformation under load; the ratio of stress to strain in the elastic region (GPa). A high Young's modulus means a material deflects very little under load. Steel (E ≈ 200 GPa) is far stiffer than rubber (E ≈ 0.01–0.1 GPa).
  • Toughness: the energy absorbed per unit volume before fracture; the area under the full stress-strain curve. Toughness combines strength and ductility: a material can be tough by being strong (like high-strength steel) or by stretching a long way before breaking (like rubber). Measured by impact tests: Charpy (notched bar struck from behind) and Izod (notched bar struck from the side).
  • Hardness: resistance to surface indentation or scratching. Tested by multiple methods: Brinell (steel/WC ball, best for castings); Rockwell (steel ball or diamond cone, measures depth); Vickers (diamond pyramid, standard for metals and ceramics); Knoop (elongated pyramid, for thin or brittle materials); Durometer (0–100 scale for polymers); Janka (half-ball penetration, for wood); Pencil test (for coatings); Shore Scleroscope (rebound height test).
  • Malleability: the ability to be permanently deformed (plastically deformed) by compressive forces (hammering, rolling) without fracturing. Gold is the most malleable metal: it can be hammered into gold leaf 0.1 μm thick.
  • Elasticity: the ability to return to original shape after the applied force is removed (elastic deformation). Occurs below the elastic limit (yield point). A rubber band is highly elastic.
  • Plasticity: the ability to permanently deform without fracturing after the elastic limit is exceeded. Essential for forming processes (forging, rolling, drawing). Opposite of brittleness.
  • Ductility: a specific form of plasticity: the ability to be drawn into wire or stretched into thin sections under tensile (pulling) forces without fracturing. Copper is highly ductile: it can be drawn into fine electrical wire.
Hardness testIndenterBest suited to
BrinellSteel or tungsten carbide ballCastings and inhomogeneous structures
RockwellSteel ball or diamond coneQuick general-purpose metal testing
VickersDiamond pyramidMetals and ceramics needing comparable values across materials
KnoopElongated diamond pyramidThin sections or brittle materials
DurometerSteel rod (0-100 scale)Polymers and elastomers
JankaSteel ball (half embedded)Wood
Ashby Chart Game preview
Interactive Tool
Ashby Chart Game

Plot and compare real materials on logarithmic property charts (strength vs. density, stiffness vs. cost) the same way materials engineers select candidate materials for a design. Try it →

Students must be able toExplain why combining materials can create composite materials more suitable for a specific purpose or context using an example.

Composite materials combine two or more constituents, a matrix (binder/continuous phase) and a reinforcement (dispersed phase), to produce a material with properties superior to either constituent alone. The three main categories are:

1. Particle-reinforced composites: Hard particles distributed in a softer matrix. The particles resist deformation and wear; the matrix transfers loads and holds particles in place.

  • Concrete: Gravel or crushed stone particles in a cement paste matrix. High compressive strength. Combined with steel rebar (reinforced concrete), it also gains tensile strength.
  • Cemented carbide (tungsten carbide + cobalt binder): WC particles provide extreme hardness for cutting tools; the cobalt matrix provides toughness to prevent brittle fracture of the tool edge.

2. Fibre-reinforced composites: Fibres embedded in a matrix (typically epoxy resin). Fibres are excellent in tension but cannot resist compression or shear without the matrix. The matrix glues fibres together, transfers load between them, and prevents buckling.

  • Carbon fibre reinforced plastic (CFRP): Carbon fibres in an epoxy matrix. Used in the Boeing 787 Dreamliner (over 50% composite by weight), high-performance sports equipment, and racing cars. Lighter than aluminium, stiffer and stronger than steel for the same mass.
  • Fibreglass (GFRP): Glass fibres in polyester or epoxy matrix. Used in boat hulls, car body panels, bathroom fixtures. Lower performance than CFRP but much cheaper.

3. Laminar (layered) composites: Layers of different materials bonded together.

  • Plywood: Thin wood veneers glued with alternating grain directions, giving balanced strength in both directions and resistance to splitting. Far more stable than solid timber.
  • Laminated glass: Two glass panes with a polyvinyl butyral (PVB) interlayer. When broken, the PVB holds the fragments together, preventing dangerous flying shards. Used in car windscreens and building façades.
  • Cardboard: Corrugated paper sandwiched between flat paper liners, forming a structural sandwich panel that uses minimal material but achieves high bending stiffness for its weight.
  • Sailcloth: Polyester, carbon or Aramid fibres laminated with polymer film in multiple orientations to withstand wind loads from all directions.
infinite Composites preview
Interactive Tool
Infinite Composites

A materials combination game, in the spirit of Neal Agarwal's Infinite Craft: combine matrix and reinforcement materials to discover new composites and learn a few things along the way. →

Students must be able toExplain how materials can be selected to react to external stimuli, including piezoelectricity, shape memory, photochromicity, magneto-rheostatic, electro-rheostatic and thermoelectricity.

Smart materials respond to a change in their environment (mechanical stress, temperature, light, electric or magnetic field) by significantly and reversibly changing one or more of their properties. This allows products that adapt to conditions without complex external control systems.

  • Piezoelectric materials: generate an electric charge when mechanically stressed (direct effect), and conversely change shape when an electric current is applied (inverse effect). Applications: ultrasonic transducers for non-destructive testing (a piezoelectric probe sends sound waves into a pipe; returning echoes stress the crystal, generating a voltage that reveals internal flaws); pressure sensors; sonar; medical ultrasound imaging; loudspeakers and microphones.
  • Shape memory alloys (SMAs): return to a pre-programmed shape when heated after being plastically deformed at a lower temperature. Nitinol (nickel-titanium alloy, discovered at the Naval Ordnance Laboratory) is the most common SMA. Applications: coronary stents (inserted compressed in martensite phase at room temperature, expand to programmed diameter at body temperature in austenite phase, opening blocked arteries without surgery); eyeglass frames that spring back to shape after bending; orthodontic wires that apply continuous gentle force as they return to shape. Pseudo-elasticity (superelasticity): some SMAs return to shape immediately on stress removal at constant temperature (no heating required).
  • Photochromic materials: darken proportionally to UV light exposure through a reversible photochemical reaction. Applications: photochromic (transition) lenses, where glass lenses contain silver chloride (AgCl) molecules; UV exposure causes a reversible oxidation-reduction reaction forming colloidal silver that absorbs up to 80% of incident light; the lens clears when UV exposure decreases. Polymer lenses use organic photochromic dyes with similar reversible reactions.
  • Electro-rheostatic (ER) fluids: suspensions of particles that form chain-like structures and become semi-solid (increase in viscosity by several orders of magnitude) when exposed to a strong electric field. The change is nearly instantaneous and fully reversible.
  • Magneto-rheostatic (MR) fluids: suspensions of iron particles in oil that stiffen dramatically when exposed to a magnetic field. Applications: automotive suspension systems (2002 Cadillac Seville STS; second-generation Audi TT), where turning up the magnetic field thickens the fluid almost instantly, firming up the ride through corners and relaxing again for a comfortable cruise; the technology also shows up in architecture, where Tokyo's National Museum of Emerging Science uses MR dampers throughout the structure to soak up sway caused by typhoon-strength wind and earthquake tremors.
  • Thermoelectric materials: generate a voltage across a temperature gradient (Seebeck effect), enabling conversion of waste heat to electricity. The reverse (Peltier effect) uses electricity to create a temperature difference for solid-state cooling (no moving parts). Applications: industrial waste heat recovery; wearable sensors powered by body heat; solid-state refrigerators and CPU coolers.
Product Spotlight
NASA's superelastic Nitinol mesh tyre

NASA's Shape-Memory Tyre

A tyre with no air to lose and a memory of its own shape.

Read spotlight →

Students must be able toExplain how biomaterials are a key part of a circular economy and can be used by designers to design out waste.

Biodegradable materials are broken down by microorganisms (bacteria, fungi, algae) into water, carbon dioxide or methane, minerals, and organic matter: non-toxic substances that can re-enter natural cycles. This contrasts with conventional synthetic plastics, which persist in the environment for hundreds of years.

Examples include natural materials (wood, cotton, wool, paper, food) and engineered biodegradable polymers such as PLA (polylactic acid), derived from corn or sugarcane starch, which is used for biodegradable packaging, cutlery, and medical sutures.

Biodegradable materials and the circular economy: The circular economy's biological cycle depends on biodegradable materials re-entering natural systems safely after use. Designers who specify biodegradable materials are:

  • Designing out waste: products that biodegrade do not accumulate as persistent pollution in landfills or oceans; they return material value to the soil as nutrients
  • Closing the loop: materials flow: product → use → composting/biodegradation → soil nutrients → new plant growth → new material → product again
  • Reducing dependency on finite feedstocks: biodegradable polymers sourced from renewable crops (corn, sugarcane, cassava) reduce reliance on fossil-fuel-derived plastics

Design considerations for biodegradability:

  • The end-of-life pathway must match the material: some biodegradable plastics (PLA) require industrial composting conditions (high temperature and specific microbial environment) and will not break down in a home compost pile or a landfill within a reasonable timeframe
  • Products labelled "biodegradable" must be accompanied by clear instructions for correct disposal; otherwise the benefit is not realised
  • Biodegradable materials must still satisfy functional requirements during the product's useful life: premature degradation from heat, moisture, or UV exposure is a design failure
  • Using biodegradable materials alongside non-biodegradable components (e.g., a biodegradable package with a plastic window) creates end-of-life complications that defeat the purpose
Discussion
Is "compostable" a lie?

A PLA cup stamped "compostable" almost never breaks down in a home compost bin, a landfill, or the ocean within any timeframe that matters. It needs an industrial composting facility: sustained heat above 55°C and a specific microbial mix that most cities don't actually operate at scale. Most "compostable" packaging ends up landfilled anyway, where it behaves close to ordinary plastic.

Is a manufacturer who prints "compostable" on the packaging, technically true but practically misleading, guilty of greenwashing? Where's the line between a genuine design-for-end-of-life decision and a marketing claim that shifts responsibility onto a disposal system that doesn't exist where the product is actually sold?

Ten questions covering all nine learning objectives, from classification and material selection through to composites, smart materials and biodegradable materials. Select one answer per question, then click "Check all answers" to see your score and the explanations.

Q1 · 3.1.1 Classifying Materials
Corrosion resistance is classified as a chemical property rather than a physical one because it:
Physical properties such as density, melting point and thermal conductivity describe what a material is and can be measured without changing it. Chemical properties describe what a material does when it meets another substance, and the reaction alters its composition. Mechanical properties describe what it can withstand under force.
Q2 · 3.1.2 Material Categories
Which statement about the three polymer groups is correct?
Thermoplastics such as polyethylene, polypropylene, ABS and PET soften on heating and can be reshaped, which is what makes them recyclable by remelting. Thermosets such as epoxy and polyester resin cross-link permanently during curing and cannot be remelted. Elastomers such as rubber and silicone are flexible and do return to shape.
Q3 · 3.1.3 Material Selection
A designer plots stiffness against density on an Ashby chart and marks out the region above 50 GPa and below 3000 kg/m³. The purpose of doing this is to:
Each material family occupies a bubble on the chart rather than a single point, because properties vary with processing and composition. Drawing a target zone shows at a glance which families fall inside it, reducing dozens of candidates to a handful worth investigating in detail. Cost, processing and sustainability are then weighed separately.
Q4 · 3.1.4 Physical Properties
A steel rod is heated from 20°C to 300°C. Which physical property determines how much it will grow in length?
The coefficient of thermal expansion gives the fractional change in length per degree of temperature change, so it predicts how far the rod grows. For mild steel it is about 11 × 10⁻⁶ K⁻¹, which is why bridges need expansion joints and pipelines need flexible connectors. Thermal conductivity describes how fast heat travels through the material, not how much it expands.
Q5 · 3.1.5 Chemical Properties
Which statement best explains why stainless steel resists corrosion while mild steel does not?
This is passivation. Chromium reacts with oxygen to form a chromium oxide layer only nanometres thick, which blocks further oxidation and reforms when damaged. Mild steel does not passivate: it forms loose, flaky rust that keeps exposing fresh metal, so degradation continues.
Q6 · 3.1.6 Mechanical Properties
A material with a high Young's modulus is characterised by:
Young's modulus is the ratio of stress to strain in the elastic region, so a high value means the material resists elastic deformation. Steel is around 200 GPa while rubber is under 0.1 GPa. Stiffness is not the same as strength or toughness: a very stiff material can still be brittle and fracture at a low load.
Q7 · 3.1.6 Mechanical Properties
Which hardness test uses a steel or tungsten carbide ball and is best suited to castings and other inhomogeneous structures?
Brinell presses a ball into the surface and leaves a comparatively wide indentation, which averages out local variation in the structure. Vickers uses a diamond pyramid and suits metals and ceramics that need comparable values, Durometer is for polymers and elastomers, and Janka is used for timber.
Q8 · 3.1.7 Composites
Which of the following is a particle-reinforced composite?
Concrete is hard particles distributed through a softer matrix, which is the definition of a particle-reinforced composite, as is cemented carbide. CFRP is fibre-reinforced, while plywood and laminated glass are laminar composites built from bonded layers.
Q9 · 3.1.8 Smart Materials
A coronary stent is inserted in a compressed form and opens to a pre-set diameter once it reaches body temperature. The material responsible is:
Shape memory alloys such as Nitinol return to a pre-programmed shape when heated after being deformed at a lower temperature, which is what lets a stent be delivered through a catheter and expand inside the artery. Piezoelectric materials respond to mechanical stress or voltage, photochromic materials to UV light, and magneto-rheostatic fluids to a magnetic field.
Q10 · 3.1.9 Biodegradable Materials
A cup moulded from PLA is labelled "compostable". Which statement is correct?
PLA is derived from crop starch and does biodegrade, but only under sustained high temperature and the microbial conditions of an industrial composting facility. Where those facilities do not exist, the product is landfilled and the environmental benefit is not realised, which is why a biodegradable specification has to be matched to a real end-of-life pathway and clear disposal instructions.
Every Paper 2 question is attached to a product. Nothing here can be answered from memory alone: read the case study first, then answer the parts in order. The tariff tells you how many creditable points to make, and the command term tells you what kind of point counts. Write your answer before you open either panel, then mark yourself against the markscheme rather than against the example.
Question 1 · A3.1 · SL and HL6 marks
Case study

Cricket bats are made from the timber of the cricket bat willow (Salix alba). Law 5 of the Laws of Cricket limits the size of the bat, and in particular of the blade, the part that strikes the ball.

In December 1979, in a Test match between Australia and England in Perth, the Australian Dennis Lillee came out to bat with an aluminium bat. It had been made as a cheap replacement for wooden bats for schools and developing countries, and the Laws did not then forbid it. The England captain, Mike Brearley, complained to the umpires that the metal bat was damaging the ball, which has a leather cover. After almost ten minutes of argument Lillee changed to a wooden bat. A few months later the Laws were amended so that the blade must be made of wood.

Front view, side view and cross-section of a cricket bat with the Law 5 maximum dimensions: overall length 96.5 cm, blade width 10.8 cm, blade depth 6.7 cm, edge 4.0 cm. The blade must be made of wood.
Figure 1: Maximum bat dimensions under Law 5 of the Laws of Cricket

Table 1: Properties of cricket bat willow and aluminium alloy

PropertyCricket bat willowAluminium alloy
Density (kg/m³)4002700
HardnessLowHigh
ToughnessHighHigh

(a) State the classification of cricket bat willow by source or origin. [1]

(b) Describe why the low density of willow matters in a bat whose size is limited by Law 5, see Figure 1 and Table 1. [2]

(c) Explain why aluminium alloy is less suitable than willow for the blade of a cricket bat, see Table 1. [3]

Example answer

(a) A natural material (a timber).

(b) Law 5 limits the length, width and depth of the bat, so a bat cannot be made bigger to give more hitting area. Within that size, the mass of the bat depends on the density of its material, and at 400 kg/m³ willow gives a full-sized bat that is still light enough to swing quickly and control.

(c) Aluminium alloy is much harder than willow, so when the leather ball hits it, the surface of the ball is damaged instead of the face of the bat denting slightly, which is what Brearley complained about. The condition of the ball matters to the bowlers throughout an innings, so a bat that damages it changes the contest for both sides. Aluminium is also nearly seven times as dense as willow, so a solid aluminium bat of the size Law 5 allows would be far too heavy to swing; it would have to be hollow or thinner, which changes how it performs. Both materials are tough, so aluminium offers no advantage in resisting breakage to make up for these problems.

Markscheme

(a) Materials are classified according to their source or origin.
• Natural material ✓
• Natural timber ✓

Award [1] for the correct classification by source or origin up to [1 max]. Accept timber or hardwood.

(b) Physical properties include aspects of a material that can be measured and observed without it changing in any way. Students must be able to explain density.
• Law 5 limits the length, width and depth, so the bat cannot be made larger ✓
• Within a fixed size, the mass of the bat depends on the density of its material ✓
• At 400 kg/m³ willow gives a full-sized blade at a manageable mass ✓
• A lighter bat can be swung faster and controlled more easily ✓
• A lighter bat causes less fatigue over a long innings ✓
• A denser material would force a smaller bat, reducing the hitting area ✓

Award [1] for each detail, leading to an account of why the low density of willow matters in a bat limited by Law 5 up to [2 max]. Credit responses that quote a value from Table 1.

(c) Identifying the most suitable material for a product involves the consideration of physical, chemical and mechanical properties. Mechanical properties include hardness and toughness.
Hardness:
• Aluminium alloy's high hardness damages the leather ball ✓
• Willow's low hardness lets the face of the bat dent slightly instead of the ball ✓
• A damaged ball behaves differently for the bowler, which changes the contest ✓
Density:
• Aluminium alloy is nearly seven times as dense as willow, 2700 against 400 kg/m³ ✓
• A solid aluminium bat of the size Law 5 allows would be too heavy to swing ✓
• It would have to be made hollow or thinner, which changes how it performs ✓
Toughness:
• Both materials are tough, so aluminium gives no advantage in resisting breakage ✓

Award [1] for each relevant reason / cause explaining why aluminium alloy is less suitable than willow for the blade of a cricket bat up to [3 max]. Award a maximum of [2] where the response refers to only one property.

Question 2 · A3.1 · SL and HL6 marks
Case study

Photochromic spectacle lenses darken in sunlight and clear again indoors, so one pair of prescription glasses can serve as both ordinary glasses and sunglasses.

Plastic photochromic lenses contain molecules that change shape when they absorb ultraviolet (UV) light. In their new shape the molecules absorb visible light, so the lens darkens. When the UV is removed, the molecules return to their original shape and the lens clears. The lenses darken in less than a minute but take about fifteen minutes to clear completely, and they become darker in cold weather and lighter in hot weather. The glass of a car windscreen blocks most UV light.

Four panels showing a pair of photochromic glasses. Indoors: clear. Outdoors in sunlight, with UV reaching the lenses: dark in under a minute. Driving a car, with the windscreen blocking UV: stays almost clear. Back indoors: about 15 minutes to clear fully. The lens darkens more in cold weather and less in hot weather.
Figure 2: How a photochromic lens responds in four situations

(a) State the external stimulus that makes the lenses darken, see Figure 2. [1]

(b) Outline why the lenses stay almost clear while the wearer is driving a car, see Figure 2. [2]

(c) Evaluate photochromic lenses as a replacement for a separate pair of prescription sunglasses, see Figure 2. [3]

Example answer

(a) Ultraviolet (UV) light.

(b) The lenses react to UV light, not to visible light. The windscreen glass blocks most of the UV, so very little reaches the lenses, the molecules do not change shape, and the lenses stay almost clear even in bright sunshine.

(c) Photochromic lenses mean one pair of glasses does both jobs, so the wearer does not have to carry a second prescription pair and swap them every time they go outside, and the lenses respond to the conditions automatically, darkening in less than a minute. Against that, they take about fifteen minutes to clear, so the wearer's vision is dimmer than it should be for some time after coming indoors. They stay almost clear in a car, which is where a driver often most needs sunglasses, and they are lighter in hot weather, when the sun is often strongest. They suit someone who mostly moves between indoors and outdoors on foot, but a wearer who drives a lot would still need separate sunglasses.

Markscheme

(a) Smart materials are materials that have one or more properties that can be significantly changed in response to changes in their environment. Students must be able to explain how materials can be selected to react to external stimuli, including photochromicity.
• Ultraviolet (UV) light ✓

Award [1] for the correct stimulus up to [1 max]. Accept UV in sunlight. Do not credit visible light, heat or sunlight alone.

(b) Smart materials have one or more properties that change significantly in response to changes in their environment.
• The lenses react to UV light, not to visible light ✓
• The windscreen glass blocks most UV light ✓
• Very little UV reaches the lenses, so the molecules do not change shape ✓
• The lenses stay almost clear even in bright sunshine ✓
• The driver may still need separate sunglasses ✓

Award [1] for each relevant brief point / summary of why the lenses stay almost clear while driving up to [2 max].

(c) Identifying the most suitable material for a product involves evaluating its properties for a specific purpose. Smart materials are selected to react to external stimuli.
Strengths:
• One pair replaces two, so the wearer does not carry and swap a second pair ✓
• The lenses respond to the conditions automatically ✓
• They darken in less than a minute on going outside ✓
• The change is reversible, so it works every day ✓
Limitations:
• They take about fifteen minutes to clear, so vision is dimmer for a time after coming indoors ✓
• They stay almost clear in a car, where sunglasses are often needed ✓
• They are lighter in hot weather, when the sun is often strongest ✓
Judgment:
• Suitable for a wearer who moves between indoors and outdoors on foot; a frequent driver would still need sunglasses ✓

Award [1] for each distinct strength / limitation, leading to an appraisal of photochromic lenses as a replacement for prescription sunglasses up to [3 max]. Award a maximum of [2] where only strengths or only limitations are given.

Question 3 · A3.1 · SL and HL10 marks
Case study · part 1

Owala's FreeSip is a reusable drinks bottle with a built-in straw and a push-button lid. The stainless steel version has two steel walls with a vacuum between them, joined only at the neck, and a lid moulded from plastic. Owala states that it keeps drinks cold for up to 24 hours, that it is free of BPA, lead and phthalates, and that it is not intended for hot or fizzy drinks.

Cutaway of the stainless steel FreeSip. Labels: lid moulded from plastic with a push button and carry loop; built-in straw; outer and inner walls of stainless steel with a vacuum between them; walls joined only at the neck; coloured finish on the outer wall.
Figure 3: Cutaway of the stainless steel FreeSip bottle

(a) Identify two chemical properties that make stainless steel suitable for the body of a drinks bottle. [2]

Case study · part 2

Heat passes through solids by conduction, and stainless steel conducts heat far less well than most other metals. A vacuum contains no material, so heat cannot be conducted across it.

(b) Outline how the construction of the bottle keeps a drink cold, see Figure 3. [2]

Case study · part 3

The lid holds a hinged cover, a push button, a carry loop and the top of the straw, all moulded from plastic. Owala recommends washing the lid on the top rack of a dishwasher.

(c) Describe why the lid is made from a polymer rather than stainless steel, see Figure 3. [2]

Case study · part 4

Owala also sells the FreeSip with a body made from Tritan, a BPA-free copolyester (a type of polymer). It has a single wall and no insulation.

Table 2: The two versions of the FreeSip

Stainless steel FreeSipTritan FreeSip
BodyTwo stainless steel walls, vacuum betweenOne Tritan wall
Density of body material (kg/m³)About 80001180
Keeps drinks coldUp to 24 hoursNot insulated
DishwasherLid on top rack; hand-washing the cup recommended to protect its finishAll parts, top rack

(d) Evaluate the Tritan FreeSip against the stainless steel FreeSip for a student who carries a bottle in a school bag all day, see Table 2. [4]

Example answer

(a) Corrosion resistance, so it does not rust in contact with water, and low reactivity, so it is food safe and does not react with drinks or affect their taste.

(b) The vacuum between the two walls contains no material, so heat from the surroundings cannot be conducted across it to the drink. The walls touch only at the neck, so the only path for conduction is a long, narrow one through stainless steel, which conducts heat poorly for a metal, and the drink stays cold for up to 24 hours.

(c) A polymer has high plasticity when heated, so the cover, hinge, button and loop can be moulded into small, detailed shapes, and its elasticity lets the hinge flex every time the lid is opened without breaking. A polymer is also much less dense than steel, which keeps the lid light, and its low thermal conductivity means little heat enters through the top of the bottle.

(d) The Tritan body is much less dense than steel, 1180 against about 8000 kg/m³, so the bottle is lighter to carry around all day, and every part can go in the dishwasher, which makes it easier to clean properly. A polymer body will also not dent if the bag is dropped, where a steel wall can. Against that, the Tritan bottle has a single wall and no insulation, so a cold drink in the morning will be at room temperature by lunchtime, where the stainless steel bottle keeps it cold for up to 24 hours. A cold drink in a single-wall bottle also collects condensation on the outside, which can wet books in the bag. The Tritan bottle suits a student who cares most about weight and easy cleaning, and the steel bottle one who wants a cold drink all day.

Markscheme

(a) Chemical properties include aspects of a material that lead to it chemically reacting with another. Students must be able to explain corrosion resistance, reactivity (food safe), hygroscopy and flammability.
• Corrosion resistance: does not rust in contact with water ✓
• Low reactivity / food safe: does not react with drinks or change their taste ✓
• Not hygroscopic: does not absorb water or odours ✓
• Resists attack by acidic drinks such as fruit juice ✓

Award [1] for each relevant chemical property identified up to [2 max]. Do not credit physical or mechanical properties such as density, thermal conductivity or strength.

(b) Physical properties include aspects of a material that can be measured and observed without it changing in any way. Students must be able to explain thermal conductivity.
• The vacuum contains no material, so heat cannot be conducted across it ✓
• The walls touch only at the neck, so the only conduction path is long and narrow ✓
• Stainless steel has a low thermal conductivity for a metal, limiting heat flow through the neck ✓
• The plastic lid conducts little heat at the opening ✓
• Heat from the surroundings reaches the drink very slowly, so it stays cold for up to 24 hours ✓

Award [1] for each relevant brief point / summary of how the construction of the FreeSip keeps a drink cold up to [2 max].

(c) Identifying the most suitable material involves the consideration of physical, chemical and mechanical properties. Mechanical properties include plasticity and elasticity.
• High plasticity when heated, so the cover, hinge, button and loop can be moulded in small, detailed shapes ✓
• Elasticity lets the hinge flex repeatedly without breaking ✓
• Low density keeps the lid light ✓
• Low thermal conductivity, so little heat enters through the lid ✓
• A steel lid would be heavier and harder to form into small, detailed parts ✓

Award [1] for each detail, leading to an account of why the FreeSip lid is made from a polymer rather than stainless steel up to [2 max].

(d) Identifying the most suitable material for a product is a complex and challenging task, involving the consideration of physical, chemical and mechanical properties and aesthetic characteristics.
Strengths of the Tritan version:
• Density 1180 against about 8000 kg/m³, so the bottle is lighter to carry all day ✓
• Every part can go in the dishwasher, so it is easier to clean ✓
• A polymer body will not dent if the bag is dropped, where a steel wall can ✓
Limitations of the Tritan version:
• A single wall with no insulation, so a cold drink warms to room temperature during the day ✓
• The stainless steel version keeps a drink cold for up to 24 hours ✓
• A cold drink in a single-wall bottle collects condensation on the outside, which can wet the bag ✓
Judgment:
• The choice depends on whether a light bottle that is easy to clean or a drink that stays cold matters more to the student ✓

Award [1] for each distinct strength / limitation, leading to an appraisal of the Tritan FreeSip against the stainless steel FreeSip for a student carrying a bottle all day up to [4 max]. Award a maximum of [2] where only strengths or only limitations are given.

MatWeb material property database
matweb.com
Free searchable database of density, Young’s modulus, tensile strength and thermal conductivity for thousands of metals, polymers, ceramics and composites. Use it when you need a real number for a real material.
The Efficient Engineer, YouTube channel
youtube.com/c/TheEfficientEngineer
Animated explanations of stress strain curves, Young’s modulus, toughness and hardness testing. The clearest free videos on the mechanical properties in 3.1.6.
Boeing 787 Dreamliner, Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_787_Dreamliner
The airframe is roughly half carbon fibre composite by weight. Covers why Boeing chose composites over aluminium, and the production problems that came with the decision.
Indentation hardness, Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indentation_hardness
Brinell, Rockwell and Vickers side by side: indenter shape, applied load, and how each number is arrived at. Supports the hardness testing in 3.1.6.
Nickel titanium (Nitinol), Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel_titanium
The shape memory alloy behind stents and orthodontic wires, including its accidental discovery at the Naval Ordnance Laboratory. Supports 3.1.8.
Ultrasonic testing, Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultrasonic_testing
How pulse echo testing finds a flaw inside a part without cutting it open, and how a piezoelectric crystal turns the returned echo into a voltage.
Photochromic lens, Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photochromic_lens
The reversible silver chloride reaction in glass lenses and the organic dyes used in plastic ones. A smart material you can buy in a shop.
Magnetorheological fluid, Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnetorheological_fluid
A fluid that stiffens within milliseconds in a magnetic field, used in adaptive car suspension and building dampers. Supports 3.1.8.
ComBat, Wikipedia
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ComBat
Source for Paper 2 Question 1: Dennis Lillee's aluminium bat in the Perth Test of December 1979, Mike Brearley's complaint that it was damaging the ball, and the change to Law 5 requiring a wooden blade.
Law 5: The bat, Marylebone Cricket Club
lawsofcricket.lords.org/laws-of-cricket/setting-up-the-game/the-bat
The current Law on bat size and materials, the source of the maximum dimensions in Figure 1: blade width 10.8 cm, depth 6.7 cm and edges 4.0 cm.
White willow, The Wood Database
wood-database.com/white-willow
Density and hardness of Salix alba, the species used for cricket bats. Source for the 400 kg/m³ density in Table 1.
Why don't Transitions lenses work well in the car?, RX Safety
rx-safety.com/2013/09/why-dont-transition-lenses-work-well-in-the-car
Why a windscreen, which blocks most UV light, stops standard photochromic lenses darkening. Source for Paper 2 Question 2, with the Photochromic lens article above for the darkening and clearing times.
FreeSip and frequently asked questions, Owala
owalalife.com/en-gb/pages/faq
Source for Paper 2 Question 3: the vacuum-insulated stainless steel FreeSip that keeps drinks cold for up to 24 hours, its care instructions, and the uninsulated Tritan version whose parts all go in the dishwasher.
Tritan TX1000 data sheet, Material Data Center
materialdatacenter.com
Eastman's Tritan copolyester, with a density of 1180 kg/m³. The stainless steel density in Table 2 is the typical value for food-grade stainless steel given by MatWeb, above.

Linking Questions

  • Why is a good understanding of material properties important when designing structural systems? (A3.2)
  • When do the physical properties of materials restrict the ability to use certain prototyping techniques? (A2.2)
  • How do the properties of a material influence the choice of manufacturing techniques for a product? (A4.1)
  • How could the continued development of biodegradable materials influence designers' ability to address sustainability and circular economy? (C2.1) (C2.2)
  • Why is a thorough understanding of materials key for effective product analysis and evaluation? (C3.1)
  • How do design decisions related to materials impact a product's life-cycle analysis? (C3.2)